Jimmy John’s Favorites Menu: Sandwiches, Prices, Calories & Nutrition Guide

The Jimmy John’s Favorites menu is made for customers who want more than a basic deli sandwich. This category includes specialty sandwiches with bold flavors, premium meat combinations, cheese, fresh vegetables, sauces, and signature toppings.

While Jimmy John’s Originals focus on classic sandwich combinations, the Favorites menu includes more distinctive choices for customers who want extra meat, bacon, spicy peppers, rich sauces, or a stronger flavor profile. The menu currently describes Favorites as specialty sandwiches for customers who want to “kick things up a notch.”

If you are searching for the Jimmy John’s Favorites menu, this guide covers the available sandwiches, ingredients, calories, nutrition, prices, customization options, and the best choices for different tastes. We’ve deconstructed all Top 12 Jimmy John’s Favorites Sandwiches to show you which one deserves your lunch money.

Jimmy John’s Favorites Sandwiches Menu With Prices 2026

The “Heavy Hitters”: 3 Popular Jimmy John’s Sandwiches 2026

These are the Best Jimmy John’s Favorites Sandwiches that define the Jimmy John’s experience in 2026.

1. #9 Italian Night Club®

The King of the Menu

• What’s Inside: Salami, Capocollo, Ham, and Provolone.
• The Insider Secret: This is a “power-up” of the #5 Vito. It adds smoked ham and extra mayo to the traditional Italian oil-and-vinegar base.
• 2026 Pro Tip: This is the #1 sandwich recommended for toasting. When the capocollo fats render under the heat, the flavor profile doubles in intensity.

2. #12 Beach Club®

The Beach Club® combines turkey, provolone, fresh vegetables, and avocado spread.

Common ingredients include:

• Turkey
• Provolone cheese
• Avocado spread
• Cucumber
• Lettuce
• Tomato
• Mayo

The avocado spread gives the sandwich a creamy texture, while cucumber adds freshness and crunch.

The Fresh & Creamy Choice

• What’s Inside: Turkey breast, Provolone, and Avocado Spread.
• The Insider Secret: It’s effectively a #4 Turkey Tom but with double cheese and the legendary avocado spread.
• 2026 Pro Tip: Always add cucumbers. The snap of the cucumber against the creaminess of the avocado creates the best texture contrast on the menu.

3. #16 Club Lulu®

The Club Lulu® combines turkey and bacon with fresh vegetables and mayo.

Common ingredients include:

• Turkey
• Bacon
• Lettuce
• Tomato
• Mayo

The turkey provides a mild flavor, while the bacon adds a smoky and savory taste.

The Ultimate Turkey & Bacon

• What’s Inside: Turkey breast and Applewood Smoked Bacon.
• The Insider Secret: It’s a Turkey Tom with bacon. Because our bacon is never “limp,” it provides a smoky crunch that makes this the most reliable club sandwich in the industry.

Jimmy John’s Favorites Calories

• You can reduce calories by removing mayo or cheese.
  
• Choosing an Unwich® instead of bread lowers carbs and calories.
  
• Adding extra vegetables can make the sandwich more filling without adding many calories.
  
• Double meat is available if you want more protein.

Jimmy John’s Favorites Allergens

Jimmy John’s Favorites may contain common allergens.

Possible allergens include:

• Wheat
• Milk
• Eggs
• Soy
• Fish in tuna-based items

The exact allergens depend on the sandwich and customization.

Customers with food allergies should:

• Review the latest official allergen guide
• Check current ingredient information
• Contact the local restaurant
• Ask about possible cross-contact

Ingredient formulas and preparation practices may change.

Jimmy John’s Favorites Prices

In 2026, the price gap between an Original and a Favorite reflects the double protein portioning.

Size	Avg. Price (Favorites)	Value Note
8-Inch Regular	$10.25 – $11.50	Best daily value
16-Inch Giant	$19.95 – $22.50	Feeds two people comfortably
Unwich® (Lettuce Wrap)	Same as 8-inch	The “Health-First” choice

In short:

• Originals = Classic foundation sandwiches
• Favorites = Most popular & upgraded options

Pro-Level Value Hack: Use the $1 Combo Deal (Meal Diamond Deal) to add a side and a drink. Since the Favorites are already premium sandwiches, adding a side for just a dollar makes this the most cost-effective premium meal in the fast-casual space.

Can You Customize Jimmy John’s Favorites?

Jimmy John’s allows customization on many menu items.

Depending on the sandwich and location, customers may be able to:

• Remove onions
• Remove tomatoes
• Remove lettuce
• Ask for less or no mayo
• Remove spicy peppers
• Add vegetables
• Add cheese
• Add extra meat
• Adjust oil and vinegar
• Choose available bread options
• Select an Unwich® option

Customization may change:

• Calories
• Protein
• Fat
• Sodium
• Price

Always review the final order before checkout.

Jimmy John’s Favorites vs Originals (What’s the Difference?)

This is a very common search query: “Jimmy John’s Favorites vs Originals.” Here’s a clear breakdown. Jimmy John’s menu is divided into two main categories. While “Originals” (#1-#6) are simple and fast, the “Favorites“ (#7-#17) are for the serious sub-lover.

Jimmy John’s Originals

Originals are the classic sandwiches that built the brand.
They usually include simpler ingredient combinations.

Examples:

• Pepe®
• Big John®
• Totally Tuna®

Originals focus on traditional deli-style builds with fewer specialty toppings.

Jimmy John’s Favorites

Favorites include some Originals but also feature more premium or upgraded sandwiches.

Examples:

• Italian Night Club®
• Club Lulu®
• Club Tuna®

Favorites often:

• Include bacon or multiple meats
• Have more flavor combinations
• Cost slightly more than basic Originals

Feature	Favorites	Originals
Flavor	Bold and specialty-focused	Classic and simple
Meat combinations	Often multiple meats	Usually simpler
Premium ingredients	More common	Varies
Bacon	Available on several options	Less common
Spicy choices	Available	Limited
Portion sizes	Regular and Giant	Regular and Giant
Customization	Available	Available

Favorites are generally better for customers who want stronger flavors or more complex ingredient combinations.

Originals may be better for customers who prefer a traditional turkey, ham, roast beef, or tuna sandwich.

How to Order Jimmy John’s Favorites

You can order a Jimmy John’s Favorite through the website, app, or participating restaurant.

Follow these steps:

1. Open the Jimmy John’s website or app.
2. Select your restaurant location.
3. Open the menu.
4. Choose the Favorites category.
5. Select a sandwich.
6. Choose the regular or Giant size.
7. Select the available bread option.
8. Customize the ingredients.
9. Add a side or drink.
10. Choose pickup or delivery.
11. Review the final price and order details.

Menu availability and customization may differ by location.

Frequently Asked Questions

What comes on a Jimmy John’s Favorite?

All “Favorites” (#7-#17) come with double portions of meat or cheese compared to the Originals. They typically include lettuce, tomato, and mayo, but you can customize them with “Freebies” like onions, hot peppers, and sauces.

What is the difference between a #4 Turkey Tom and a #12 Beach Club?

The #4 Turkey Tom is an “Original” with turkey and mayo. The #12 Beach Club is a “Favorite” that adds double provolone cheese, avocado spread, and cucumbers. If you want a more filling, creamy sandwich, go with the #12.

Which Jimmy John’s Favorite has the most protein?

The #10 Hunter’s Club® (Double Roast Beef & Provolone) and the #9 Italian Night Club® are the protein leaders. If you are tracking macros in 2026, the #10 as an Unwich is a massive protein hit with almost zero carbs.

Can I get Favorites as a 16-inch Giant?

Yes! Every Favorite sandwich can be upgraded to a 16-inch Giant Sub, which is perfect for sharing or for those with a “Freaky Large” appetite.

Can I get the Favorites on Sliced Wheat bread?

Yes. While French bread is the standard, our thick-sliced 9-Grain Wheat is a fantastic pairing for the bacon-heavy subs like the #17 Ultimate Porker®.

What is the most popular sandwich at Jimmy John’s?

Popularity varies by location and customer preference. The Spicy East Coast Italian is a well-known choice for customers who enjoy spicy Italian meats, while the J.J.B.L.T.® is popular with bacon lovers.

How many calories are in the Spicy East Coast Italian?

Jimmy John’s lists the regular Spicy East Coast Italian at approximately 670 calories. The Giant version is listed at approximately 2,050 calories.

What is the healthiest Jimmy John’s favorite?

The Turkey Tom® is usually one of the lighter options, especially when ordered with less mayo or as an Unwich®.

Are Jimmy John’s Favorites available everywhere?

Yes, these sandwiches are part of the main menu and are available at most U.S. locations.

Final Expert Take

The Jimmy John’s Favorites category is where Jimmy John’s truly beats the competition. While other shops charge extra for every slice of cheese or avocado, the Favorites are bundled for flavor. If you’re a first-timer, start with the #9 Italian Night Club. If you’re looking for a clean, gourmet bite, the #12 Beach Club is the gold standard of 2026.