10 Best Jimmy John’s Sandwiches: Top Picks, Calories & What to Order in 2026
Jimmy John’s doesn’t present a simple official nationwide ranking saying that one sandwich is definitively the most popular.
However, several sandwiches are prominently featured in Jimmy John’s current restaurant pages, including the #9 Italian Night Club, #4 Turkey Tom, #12 Beach Club, #16 Club Lulu, #11 Country Club, and #5 Vito.
If you’re ordering Jimmy John’s for the first time, the #9 Italian Night Club is a strong starting point if you enjoy Italian-style subs. For something milder, start with the Turkey Tom.
The #9 Italian Night Club is our top overall pick for a bold, classic deli-style sandwich. If you prefer something lighter, the #4 Turkey Tom is a better choice, while the #7 Spicy East Coast Italian is the pick for customers who want extra meat and heat.
10 Best Jimmy John’s Sandwiches
| Rank | Sandwich | Best For | Regular Calories* |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | #9 Italian Night Club | Best overall | 930 |
| 2 | #7 Spicy East Coast Italian | Best spicy sandwich | 850 |
| 3 | #12 Beach Club | Best turkey sandwich | 850 |
| 4 | #8 Billy Club | Best roast beef & ham | 810 |
| 5 | #13 Jimmy Cubano | Best smoky sandwich | 710 |
| 6 | #16 Club Lulu | Best turkey & bacon | 690 |
| 7 | #14 Bootlegger Club | Best simple meat combo | 680 |
| 8 | #11 Country Club | Best classic deli flavor | 780 |
| 9 | #5 Vito | Best Italian Original | 570 |
| 10 | #4 Turkey Tom | Best lighter classic | 480 |
Calories shown are for regular sandwiches on French bread based on Jimmy John’s published menu information. Actual nutrition can change with bread, size, toppings, and customizations.
1. #9 Italian Night Club — Best Overall Jimmy John’s Sandwich
The #9 Italian Night Club is our top pick because it combines salami, capocollo, ham, provolone, onion, oil and vinegar, and oregano-basil into one of Jimmy John’s boldest classic combinations.
According to Jimmy John’s published menu, the regular version contains 930 calories, while the Giant version contains 1,860 calories.
What’s on the Italian Night Club?
The sandwich includes:
- Salami
- Capocollo
- Ham
- Provolone
- Onion
- Oil and vinegar
- Oregano-basil
- Lettuce, tomato and mayo as standard sandwich components
The combination delivers the unmistakable Italian deli profile many customers expect from a loaded sub.
Why we rank it #1
The Italian Night Club isn’t subtle. It’s meaty, salty, savory and packed with different textures.
The oil and vinegar help cut through the richness of the meats and cheese, while the vegetables provide freshness.
Best for: Italian-sub lovers and customers who want a substantial, flavorful sandwich.
Watch out: It’s one of the higher-calorie regular sandwiches on the menu.
2. #7 Spicy East Coast Italian — Best Spicy Jimmy John’s Sandwich
If the Italian Night Club sounds good but you want more heat, the #7 Spicy East Coast Italian is an excellent alternative.
Jimmy John’s lists it with double salami, double capocollo, provolone, hot peppers, onion, oil and vinegar, and oregano-basil. The regular sandwich is listed at 850 calories.
Why it’s one of the best
The double meat gives this sandwich a substantial bite, while hot peppers bring the heat.
It’s particularly appealing if you prefer sandwiches with:
- Extra meat
- Salty cured-meat flavor
- Hot peppers
- Italian-style seasoning
- A stronger overall flavor
Is the Spicy East Coast Italian actually spicy?
It’s one of the better choices on the Jimmy John’s menu if you want noticeable pepper heat, but the overall experience is still centered on the meat, cheese and Italian seasoning.
Best for: Spicy sandwich fans.
Our tip: If you already enjoy the Italian Night Club, this is one of the easiest upgrades when you want extra heat.
3. #12 Beach Club — Best Turkey Sandwich
The #12 Beach Club is one of the best choices for customers who want turkey without settling for a basic turkey sandwich.
It combines turkey, double provolone, avocado spread and cucumber. Jimmy John’s lists the regular French-bread version at 850 calories.
Why we like it
The avocado spread changes the sandwich significantly.
Instead of relying only on turkey and cheese, you get:
- Turkey
- Creamy avocado
- Double provolone
- Crisp cucumber
- Fresh vegetables
The result is a creamy, fresh-tasting sandwich with more personality than a basic deli turkey sub.
Best for: Turkey lovers who want a richer sandwich.
Best alternative: #4 Turkey Tom if you want a simpler and lighter turkey option.
4. #8 Billy Club — Best Roast Beef & Ham Sandwich
The #8 Billy Club is a strong choice if you can’t decide between roast beef and ham.
It’s made with:
- Roast beef
- Ham
- Provolone
- Yellow mustard
The regular sandwich is listed at 810 calories.
Why it’s worth ordering
The combination is straightforward but effective.
Roast beef provides the deeper beefy flavor, ham adds saltiness, provolone brings creaminess, and yellow mustard adds acidity and tang.
Unlike some of the heavily loaded Italian sandwiches, the Billy Club keeps the ingredient list relatively focused.
Best for: Roast beef fans who also want ham.
Flavor profile: Savory, meaty, cheesy and slightly tangy.
5. #13 Jimmy Cubano — Best Smoky & Tangy Sandwich
The #13 Jimmy Cubano is different from many of Jimmy John’s standard sandwiches.
It’s made with bacon, ham, provolone, sliced pickles and yellow mustard, and Jimmy John’s menu specifies that it comes without lettuce or tomato. The regular sandwich is listed at 710 calories.
What makes the Jimmy Cubano different?
The pickles and mustard provide a sharp, tangy contrast to the bacon, ham and cheese.
It’s a particularly good choice if you don’t care for sandwiches overloaded with lettuce and tomato.
Why we rank it highly
You get several strong flavors without an enormous amount of ingredients.
Best for: Bacon lovers and customers who enjoy pickles and mustard.
Try it if: You want something different from the traditional Italian-style sandwich.
6. #16 Club Lulu — Best Turkey & Bacon Sandwich
Turkey and bacon are a classic combination, and the #16 Club Lulu keeps the formula simple.
The sandwich features turkey and bacon, with the standard sandwich preparation adding the usual vegetables and mayo. Jimmy John’s lists the regular French-bread version at 690 calories.
Why it’s a great choice
Turkey provides a relatively mild meat flavor, while bacon adds smoky, salty richness.
That makes the Club Lulu a good middle ground between:
- A light turkey sandwich
- A richer bacon sandwich
- A fully loaded deli sub
Best for: Turkey-and-bacon fans.
Best feature: A familiar flavor combination without the complexity of an Italian sub.
7. #14 Bootlegger Club — Best Simple Meat Combination
The #14 Bootlegger Club combines roast beef and turkey.
Jimmy John’s lists the regular sandwich at 680 calories.
Why choose the Bootlegger Club?
It’s one of the better choices when you want two different meats without adding a lot of additional flavors.
The roast beef brings a richer taste, while turkey keeps the sandwich from becoming too heavy.
It’s also a useful choice for customers who like deli-meat combinations but don’t necessarily want salami or capocollo.
Best for: Roast beef and turkey fans.
Flavor profile: Mild, savory and meaty.
8. #11 Country Club — Best Classic Deli Sandwich
The #11 Country Club combines turkey, ham and provolone.
The regular version is listed at 780 calories.
Why it’s a reliable choice
There’s nothing complicated about the Country Club.
Turkey and ham provide complementary flavors, while provolone adds richness.
It’s a good choice if you want a classic deli-style sandwich without spicy peppers, strong Italian seasoning or specialty toppings.
Best for: Classic sandwich lovers.
Good for: Lunch when you want something familiar and filling.
9. #5 Vito — Best Italian Original
The #5 Vito is one of Jimmy John’s classic Original sandwiches.
It contains:
- Salami
- Capocollo
- Provolone
- Onion
- Oil and vinegar
- Oregano-basil
Unlike many of the other sandwiches, the Vito does not come with mayo as part of its standard build. Jimmy John’s lists the regular French-bread Vito at 570 calories.
Why it’s on our list
The Vito delivers the Italian flavor profile in a smaller and simpler package than some of the heavier Favorites.
If you like salami and capocollo but don’t need multiple layers of meat, it’s an excellent choice.
Best for: Italian sandwich fans who want a classic Original.
Bonus: It’s one of the lower-calorie options on this list.
10. #4 Turkey Tom — Best Lighter Classic
The #4 Turkey Tom is our pick for the best lighter classic sandwich.
Jimmy John’s lists the regular French-bread Turkey Tom at 480 calories.
It features turkey with the standard sandwich vegetables and mayo.
Why it’s worth ordering
Sometimes you don’t need an oversized, heavily loaded sandwich.
The Turkey Tom gives you:
- Turkey
- Fresh vegetables
- Bread
- A straightforward flavor profile
Jimmy John’s also offers the option to order sandwiches as an Unwich, replacing bread with a lettuce wrap.
Best for: A lighter lunch or customers who prefer turkey.
Best Jimmy John’s Sandwiches by Category
Not everyone wants the same thing from a sandwich. Here’s a quicker way to choose.
| What You Want | Best Choice |
| Best overall | #9 Italian Night Club |
| Best spicy | #7 Spicy East Coast Italian |
| Best turkey | #12 Beach Club |
| Best roast beef | #8 Billy Club |
| Best bacon sandwich | #16 Club Lulu |
| Best Italian Original | #5 Vito |
| Best lighter option | #4 Turkey Tom |
| Best simple meat combo | #14 Bootlegger Club |
| Best classic deli sandwich | #11 Country Club |
| Best pickle & mustard flavor | #13 Jimmy Cubano |
What Is the Best Jimmy John’s Sandwich for First-Time Customers?
For a first order, we’d narrow it down to three choices:
Want a bold sandwich?
#9 Italian Night Club
Want something spicy?
#7 Spicy East Coast Italian
Want something simple?
#4 Turkey Tom
This approach is easier than trying to choose between every sandwich on the menu.
What Is the Best Jimmy John’s Sandwich for Lunch?
For a normal lunch, the best choice depends on how hungry you are.
Light lunch
#4 Turkey Tom
Balanced lunch
#14 Bootlegger Club
Hearty lunch
#9 Italian Night Club
Spicy lunch
#7 Spicy East Coast Italian
Pairing your sandwich with a smaller side rather than automatically adding chips and dessert can also help keep the meal more manageable.
What Is the Best Jimmy John’s Sandwich for Delivery?
The best delivery sandwich depends partly on how you like your bread and toppings.
For delivery, consider sandwiches with strong flavors that remain enjoyable after a short travel time.
Our picks:
Best overall: #9 Italian Night Club
Best spicy: #7 Spicy East Coast Italian
Best simple: #4 Turkey Tom
Jimmy John’s offers delivery and pickup through its online ordering system at participating locations.
Frequently Asked Questions About Jimmy John’s Sandwiches
What are the 10 best Jimmy John’s sandwiches?
Our 10 picks are the #9 Italian Night Club, #7 Spicy East Coast Italian, #12 Beach Club, #8 Billy Club, #13 Jimmy Cubano, #16 Club Lulu, #14 Bootlegger Club, #11 Country Club, #5 Vito and #4 Turkey Tom.
What is the best sandwich at Jimmy John’s?
The #9 Italian Night Club is our top overall pick because it combines salami, capocollo, ham, provolone, onion and Italian-style seasonings into a bold, filling sandwich.
What is the healthiest sandwich at Jimmy John’s?
There isn’t one universally healthiest sandwich, but the #4 Turkey Tom is one of the lighter choices in this ranking at 480 calories for a regular French-bread sandwich.
What is the most popular Jimmy John’s sandwich?
Jimmy John’s does not publish a definitive nationwide popularity ranking, but the #9 Italian Night Club and other Favorites are prominently featured on current Jimmy John’s location pages.
Which Jimmy John’s sandwich is best for protein?
Meat-heavy options such as the Billy Club, Italian Night Club, Spicy East Coast Italian and Bootlegger Club can be substantial protein choices, while Jimmy John’s also offers a dedicated Protein Packed category.
What is the lowest-calorie sandwich on this list?
The #4 Turkey Tom is the lowest-calorie sandwich in our top 10, with 480 calories for the regular French-bread version.
Can I get a Jimmy John’s sandwich without bread?
Yes. Jimmy John’s offers the Unwich, which replaces the bread with a lettuce wrap.
Which Jimmy John’s sandwich is the spiciest?
The #7 Spicy East Coast Italian is one of the strongest choices for heat because it includes hot peppers along with double salami and double capocollo.
What sandwich should I get at Jimmy John’s for the first time?
Try the #9 Italian Night Club for a bold Italian-style sandwich, the #7 Spicy East Coast Italian for heat, or the #4 Turkey Tom for a simpler option.
Are Jimmy John’s sandwiches customizable?
Yes. Jimmy John’s allows customers to add or remove ingredients, choose different bread formats, and order sandwiches such as the Unwich depending on the menu and location.
Final Verdict: Which Jimmy John’s Sandwich Should You Order?
There’s no single sandwich that will be perfect for everyone, but the menu makes it easy to match your order to what you’re craving.
For the best overall experience: Go with the #9 Italian Night Club.
For heat: Choose the #7 Spicy East Coast Italian.
For turkey: Try the #12 Beach Club.
For roast beef: Order the #8 Billy Club.
For bacon: Choose the #16 Club Lulu.
For pickles and mustard: Try the #13 Jimmy Cubano.
For a classic Italian Original: Go with the #5 Vito.
For a lighter option: Choose the #4 Turkey Tom.
And if you’re trying to control calories or carbohydrates, remember that size and customization matter just as much as the sandwich itself. Jimmy John’s offers regular, Giant and Little John formats, along with the Unwich lettuce-wrap option.
For the latest prices, availability and customization options, check your local Jimmy John’s menu before ordering because menu details can vary by restaurant.
